< Back

Combination Deals in Israel: Who Is Your Seller?

Q: Is a landowner's apartment cheaper and is that a warning sign?

Prices vary and are not a legal signal. What matters is whether the guarantees and the chain of obligations between landowner, developer and you are documented; have your lawyer map them before comparing prices.

Q: Who fixes defects if I bought from the landowner?

It depends on the contract and on the arrangements between landowner and developer. Insist that the contract names who is responsible under the Sale (Apartments) Law and how to reach them.

Q: Can the project collapse if landowner and developer fall out?

Disputes between the parties can delay or derail a project. Ask what protection your contract gives in that event and whether your security under the Assurance of Investments Law covers return of your money.

Construction site with a split-ownership diagram of apartments between landowner and developer

A combination deal (kombinatzia) is a transaction in which a landowner gives a developer part of the land, or part of the rights in it, in exchange for finished apartments built by the developer on the remainder. The project's apartments are then divided: some belong to the developer, some to the landowner. When you buy, your seller may be either of them, and that single fact determines which law protects your money, who owes you warranty obligations, and what can go wrong between signing and delivery.

Two sellers in one building

In a typical combination project the land remains registered in the landowner's name in the Land Registry under the Land Law 5729-1969 until the developer's share is transferred, often at the end. The developer's rights are usually protected by a caveat (he'arat azhara). Apartments allocated to the developer are sold by the developer; apartments allocated to the landowner are sold by the landowner, sometimes through the same sales office and with the same marketing material.

Ask directly: who is the seller named in the contract, the developer or the landowner?
Obtain the combination agreement, or at least the schedule that allocates apartments between the parties, and confirm that your apartment is in your seller's share.
Check the Land Registry extract for the owner, the developer's caveat and any mortgage registered by the developer's financing bank.

Buying from the developer

When the developer sells an apartment it built or is building, the Sale (Apartments) Law 5733-1973 and the Sale (Apartments) (Assurance of Investments) Law 5735-1974 apply in the ordinary way. The developer must give you one of the securities listed in the Assurance of Investments Law, such as a bank guarantee or insurance policy, before receiving payments beyond the threshold set in that law, and payments in bank-financed projects normally go through the project's protected account using payment vouchers.

Confirm which security you receive and that it is issued in your name for each payment.
Confirm that the developer's rights against the landowner are secured, because your apartment can only be transferred to you once the developer receives its share.
Ask what happens if the combination agreement is terminated: your contract with the developer may not bind the landowner.

Buying from the landowner

A landowner selling apartments from its share is also a seller, but the position is less uniform. The landowner may be a private individual, a group of heirs or a company, and the construction is being done by someone else. Whether and how the Assurance of Investments Law applies, and who is responsible for the building's defects under the Sale (Apartments) Law, must be established from the documents rather than assumed.

Ask for the landowner's written confirmation that the apartment is in its allocation and that the developer is bound to build and deliver it to you.
Ask whether the developer's construction guarantee to the landowner extends to buyers of the landowner's apartments, and if so, how.
Check whether the developer's bank has a mortgage over the land that could affect the landowner's apartments, and how your apartment will be released from it.
Make sure a caveat is registered in your favour against the landowner's title immediately after signing.

Tax and registration points

The Real Estate Taxation Law 5723-1963 treats the combination transaction itself as a sale between landowner and developer, with its own tax consequences; your purchase is a separate taxable event with purchase tax payable by you. Registration of your apartment depends on the building being registered as a condominium under the Land Law, which in turn depends on the certificate of completion under the Planning and Building Law 5725-1965. Ask who is responsible for condominium registration and whether the contract sets a deadline.

Common mistakes

Assuming the company in the sales office is the seller.
Not reading the apartment allocation schedule in the combination agreement.
Paying the landowner directly outside any protected payment mechanism.
Overlooking the financing bank's mortgage over the entire land.
Treating warranty obligations as automatic when the seller is not the builder.

FAQ

Is a landowner's apartment cheaper and is that a warning sign?